[TNG] Rightful Heir

[TNG] Season 6, Episode 23: Rightful Heir

Rating: 2

Star Trek can often have a well meaning but ultimately condescending feeling when dealing with religion, and Rightful Heir is a good example of that. Here, and in most other religion themed episodes, it usually boils down to a sentiment along the lines of “belief in something is good!” with the implication generally being the actual thing that is being believed isn’t really important. It’s a baffling position to take, but if the problems with this episode were purely thematic, it could still earn a higher rating from us. Unfortunately, it’s a weirdly dull episode, considering Klingon Jesus turns up. A huge factor is that Kahless should be an incredibly compelling personality. There would be a ton of great drama to mine from a faithful person encountering the real subject of their devotion, and how that subject both aligns and differs from the worshipper’s preconceived notion of them. But Kahless is pretty bland – and instead of Worf dealing with that more fully, the time is split so that there can be some dry and predictable intrigue around whether he’s real or not. The whole thing is never bad enough to be a 1, but there’s nothing really to recommend.

Read more at Memory Alpha

Notes:

Worf is one minute late! This is so alarming that Riker immediately summons a security force to Worf’s room to see what in the hot heck is going on.
Worf didn’t show up because he was still thinking about Birthright part II.
So he needs to take some time off to pray for Kahless’ return.
That was easy!
Worf doubts it’s the real Kahless.
Worf: “it is not an empirical matter. It is a matter of faith.” 🙄 no, its empirical.
They had some of Kahless’ blood laying around to see if the DNA matches.
It matches, but Gowron still doesn’t believe. There is only one way to know if it’s truly Kahless….
… Fight! That’s right. Gowron beats him. Case closed, end of episode.
This guy says “ok maybe he’s a clone I made, oops” (paraphrasing)
Worf says people still need something to believe in and that “despite the facts, they will still believe.” On the second point you are probably right, Worf. Doesn’t seem like the kind of thing to embrace though?
They make him emperor because he’s still a pretty good guy and all. But because he’s fake Kahless the emperor position is just honorary. Good compromise y’all.

<Previous Episode 

Next Episode>